Infrastructure investment can create enormous economic and social benefits, and there exists a large gap in infrastructure financing globally. Infrastructure fund is a critical way to improve the liquidity of infrastructure projects and enhance the professional management ability of investment. The paper fills the gap in the academic research of infrastructure funds, namely investigating investor preferences andpossible conflict of interest between investors and fund companies.
This paper utilizes a unique infrastructure fund dataset from Thomson Reuters Eikon, which includes 4,843 international infrastructure funds sold publicly between January 2005 and June 2019. In terms of methodology, the paper employs models of fund flow determinants from literature of mutual funds to study investors' preferences and flow chasing behavior, and utilizes models of fund expense ratio to analyze conflict of interest between investors and fund companies. In addition, the paper introduces several infrastructure fund or fund company characteristics to identify the driving factors behind the phenomena. Robustness tests are also carried out.
Evidences indicate investors' preferences toward fund companies with higher customer fidelity, or with global geographical focus, after controlling for fund level variables. The article also uncovers a flow-chasing pattern of investor behavior on fund company level, and finds it intensified with the opacity of information and uncertainty of returns. Moreover, principal-agent problem exists since infrastructure funds are able to charge higher fees even with worse before-fee performance, which can be explained by fund characteristics and year effects, especially with the funds having global focus,being income-distributed or not team-managed.
Policy implications are provided for developing efficient and stable infrastructure financing market and for investor protection. First, deepen financial supply-side reform and promote financial innovation, expand the sources of capital for infrastructure, enhance sustainability and stability of infrastructure financing. Second, prevent and resolve major financial risks that might be caused by expanding infrastructure financing,strengthen the requirements on information disclosure, reduce investors' sensitivity to fluctuations of short-term returns, and mitigate the conflict of interests between investors and asset management institutions. Efforts should also be made to strengthen the education of investors, adopt targeted regulatory measures in regards to some fund characteristics to prevent market risks that might be caused by investors' irrational behaviors.
Key words
Infrastructure Fund /
Investor Preference /
Principal-Agent Problem
{{custom_keyword}} /
{{custom_sec.title}}
{{custom_sec.title}}
{{custom_sec.content}}
References
[1] 路磊,黄京志,吴博. 基金排名变化和羊群效应变化[J]. 金融研究,2014(9):177-191
[2] 伍戈,基建投资,定力还是发力?[N]. 中国金融四十人论坛,2019年7月12日
[3] 肖峻,石劲. 基金业绩与资金流量:我国基金市场存在“赎回异象”吗?[J]. 经济研究,2011,46(1):112-125
[4] 余音,姚彤,张峥,江嘉骏. 期末溢价与基金家族策略——来自中国公募基金市场的证据[J]. 金融研究,2018,(5):154-171
[5] 曾建光,伍利娜,王立彦,諶家蘭. 技术进步、信息透明度与开放式基金的资金流量——基于中国开放式基金强制采用XBRL的证据[J]. 金融研究,2014(8):131-145
[6] Agarwal V,Gay G D,Ling L.Window Dressing in Mutual Funds[J]. Review of Financial Studies,2014,37(11):3133-3170
[7] Bailey W,Kumar A,Ng D.Behavioral Biases of Mutual Fund Investors[J]. Journal of Financial Economics,2011,102(1):1-27
[8] Berk J,Green R.Mutual Fund Flows and Performance in Rational Markets[J]. Journal of Political Economy,2004,112(6):1269-1295
[9] Bitsch F.Cash Flow Stability versus Transparency:What Do Investors Value about Listed Infrastructure Funds? [M]. in J. Jay Choi,Heibatollah Sami(ed.)Transparency and Governance in A Global World,Emerald Group Publishing Limited,2012:199-229
[10] Chen J,Hong H,Huang M,Kubik J D.Does Fund Size Erode Mutual Fund Performance?The Role of Liquidity and Organization[J]. American Economic Review,2004,94(5):1276-1302
[11] Choi J,Laibson D,Madrian B.Why Does the Law of One Price Fail?An Experiment on Index Mutual Funds[J]. Review of Financial Studies. 2010,23:1405-1432
[12] Christoffersen S E K,Musto D K. Demand Curves and the Pricing of Money Management[J]. Review of Financial Studies,2002,15:1499-1524
[13] Del Guercio D,Tkac P A.Star Power:The Effect of Monrningstar Ratings on Mutual Fund Flow[J]. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,2008,43(4):907-936
[14] Del Guercio D,Genc E,Tran H.Playing Favorites:Conflicts of Interest in Mutual Fund Management[J]. Journal of Financial Economics,2018,128(3):535-557
[15] Díaz Mendoza A C,López‐Espinosa G,Martínez M A. The Efficiency of Performance Based Fee Funds[J]. European Financial Management,2014,20(4):825-855
[16] Donaldson D,Hornbeck R.Railroads and American Economic Growth:A“Market Access”Approach,Quarterly Journal of Economics,2016,131(2):799-858
[17] Donaldson D.Railroads of the Raj:Estimating the Impact of Transportation Infrastructure,American Economic Review,2018,108(4-5):899-934
[18] Ferrari M,Giovannini A,Pompei M.The Challenge of Infrastructure Financing[J]. Oxford Review of Economic Policy,2016,32(3):446-474
[19] Gil-Bazo J,Ruiz-Verdu' P. When Cheaper Is Better:Fee Determination in the Market for Equity Mutual Funds[J]. Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization,2008,67:871-885
[20] Gil-Bazo J,Ruiz-Verdu' P. The Relation between Price and Performance in the Mutual Fund Industry[J]. Journal of Finance,2009,64:2153-2183
[21] Grinblatt M,Titman S.Mutual Fund Performance:An Analysis of Quarterly Portfolio Holdings[J]. Journal of Business. 1989,62(3):393-416
[22] Huang J,Wei K D,Yan H.Participation Costs and the Sensitivity of Fund Flows to Past Performance[J]. Journal of Finance,2007,62:1273-1311
[23] Iannotta G,Navone M.The Cross-Section of Mutual Fund Fee Dispersion[J]. Journal of Banking and Finance,2012,36(3):846-856
[24] Khorana A,Servaes H,Tufano P.Mutual Fund Fees around the World[J]. Review of Financial Studies,2009,22:1279-1310
[25] Muñoz F,Vicente R.Hindsight Effect:What Are the Actual Cash Flow Timing Skills of Mutual Fund Investors?[J]. Journal of Empirical Finance,2018,45:181-193
[26] Nanda V,Wang Z J,Zheng L.Family Values and the Star Phenomenon:Strategies of Mutual Fund Families[J]. Review of Financial Studies,2004,17(3):667-698
[27] Newell G,Peng H W,De Francesco A.The Performance of Unlisted Infrastructure Investments in Investment Portfolios[J]. Journal of Property Research,2011,28(1):59-74
[28] Orr R J,The Rise of Infra Funds. Project Finance International-Global Infrastructure Report 2007,2007:2-12
[29] Stambaugh R F.Presidential Address:Investment Noise and Trends[J]. Journal of Finance,2014,69(4):1415-1453
{{custom_fnGroup.title_en}}
Footnotes
{{custom_fn.content}}